Buy Mysteries

Posts Tagged ‘Salem’

Death in Salem by Eleanor Kuhns

Eleanor Kuhns is the librarian-turned historical mystery writer.  I am in awe of her ability to work full time as assistant director of Goshen Public Library in New York and still have the time to do all the research and writing that is required to produce a high quality historical mystery series.  “Death in Salem” again features itinerant weaver Will Rees and his wife Lydia and is set in Maine and surrounding states in the 1790s.

Rees embarks on the trip south from Maine to Massachusetts to sell his wares to earn a few extra dollars for his growing family.  In the last novel in the “A Will Rees Mystery” series Rees and his wife acquire a brood of kids when they encounter a woman who is dying and who’s orphaned children they decide to adopt.  In Salem Will visits with his Revolutionary War compatriot nicknamed Twig, who has become the town undertaker.  Will accompanies his friend to the funeral averil (wake or post-funeral gathering) for the wife of a prominent merchant fleet owner who has died under somewhat mysterious circumstances after years of being bed-ridden.  She was a member of a prominent whaling family that lives several miles from Salem.  When the black slave servant of the dead woman’s household is arrested for her murder on little to no evidence, Twig asks Will to investigate to save the life of his lover, the black woman.

It is clear that the Sheriff is either incompetent or in on some wider plot tied in to this case.  Leads investigated by Will are far-ranging and suggest the possibility of an insurance fraud cover-up, possible smuggling, possible mercy killing, and several other potential reasons for the growing number of murders.

The one thing that I find a little bothersome, and particularly as the author moves forward with this series, is the lack of opportunity to include Lydia on the whole plot.  Lydia arrives late on the scene in “Death in Salem,” and while her insights do help to solve the case, this series is more satisfying when Will and Lydia work as a team from the start. Because the children clearly need Lydia at home the author is somewhat boxed in because someone must stay home with the kids while Will is plying his wares throughout the northeast. Perhaps the next novel will need to be set at their farm in Maine because there are a growing number of family issues to resolve that could be woven into the pattern of the next mystery.

Death in Salem” is a most insightful mystery.  So few mysteries these days are based on such thorough scholarship.  I learned a lot I did not know before about everything from slavery in the early northern states to the differences between the merchant ship trade and the whaling trade in late 18th century America.  Lovers of Historical mysteries set in colonial America will love this one!

Liz Nichols

Technorati Tags: , , , , , , ,

Wicked Appetite by Janet Evanovich

I believe Lizzie Tucker, the cupcake baker from Salem, MA, is a new character for Evanovich. She reminds me of the characters in the TV show about the pie maker from a few years ago. Lizzie inherited a house from her Great Aunt Ophelia in Marblehead sometime after graduating from chef school. She flunked gravy making but seemed to excel at baking cupcakes. It appears that she has special cupcake making powers.

One character we’ve seen in other Evanovich books is Diesel. When he’s not second in command for a security agency in Trenton he seems to be hanging out in Salem and Marblehead looking for some special treasure and the totems that will lead to the treasure. Diesel is trying to figure out where to find this special treasure before his cousin Wulf gets to it. He recruits Lizzie because she has a special ability to sense when the totems that will lead to the treasure are near.

I just don’t find this particular cast of characters very compelling, and the plot is even more silly than the usual Evanovich plot. At least with Stephanie Plum one can picture the kind of hot water a bail bond bounty hunter might get in to and the kind of low-life they might run in to. Here you’ve got would-be witches, werewolves and other weird characters who make Diesel look positively normal in comparison.

Many will read and enjoy Wicked Appetite simply because it is Evanovich. I think I’ll stick with the Plum series, and I definitely vote for keeping Diesel in Trenton.

Liz Nichols

Technorati Tags: , , , ,